Fire damage is devastating to the occupants and owners of a facility. The first responders battling the fire and those technicians tasked to perform emergency services, cleaning, and remediation may be exposed to safety and health risks. The building can be impacted as a whole or in part, affecting structure materials, assemblies, and contents. Fire Damage assessment and investigation is a critical process requiring a stepwise approach that involves removing fire-damaged materials, assemblies, and smoke residues and restoring the property to a safe and healthy environment.
Cleaning and remediating fire and smoke damage requires a stepwise approach, which begins with damage assessment and investigation. The RIA Guide for Fire and Smoke Damage Repair references this two-part process, which is further detailed in the brand new IICRC S700 Standard for Professional Fire and Smoke Damage Restorations. The damage assessment includes appropriately identifying the areas affected by the fire and the extent of the damage to formulate a remediation work plan (RWP) or protocol. However, before the damage assessment and investigation, a job site analysis (JSA) and job hazards analysis (JHA) should be conducted to assess the damage related to safety and health. The JSA/JHA evaluation is essential to evaluate any damage to the structure’s integrity and potentially hazardous chemicals and materials that resulted from the fire event that could pose safety and health concerns to the worker.
Dehumidification should be set after addressing safety and health, developing power, assessing indoor air quality air filter devices (AFD), and the initial removal of structure fire debris. The drying methodology should include applying direct energy to moisture-affected materials, assemblies, systems, and contents. After debris has been removed, additional standing water may need to be removed. At this stage, the site is ready for cleaning of the smoke damage. Addressing soot and smoke damage can be challenging for restorers, as particles and residues can penetrate the structures’ envelope, structural defects, and structural modifications that can contribute to hidden odor(s) and malodors. Restorers and competent professionals (industrial hygienists) know that smoke may permit fire particles and residue to condense or be deposited onto building materials, assemblies, and contents surfaces or be adsorbed based on porosity. Restorers and competent professionals should be able to identify areas of impact on building surfaces to create a complete and adequate RWP or Protocol. Restorers rely on visual and olfactory inspection as a primary method for preliminary determination of effects. At the same time, the competent professional can employ testing and analytical methodology to confirm smoke impact and scope if required.
These six below have no actual scientific value for the assessor, investigator, or third party or a substitute for certified laboratory analysis. These should only be used as a potential recommendation to the cleaner or restorer and a third party as a visual aid and preliminary remediation work plan (RWP) or protocol.
Dry Smoke: residue “dark gray to black in color, ashy, dry particle resulting from vigorous, oxygen-rich combustion. Residues are comprised of burnt cellulose materials such as wood and paper. Distribution varies depending on the severity of the fire and effects from other damage mechanisms such as temperature. Particle levels at the source(s) are in higher contraction, and as the assessor or investigator moves away from the source(s), the particles decrease.
Wet Smoke: Sticky, penetrating residue from slow-burning or smoldering, oxygen-starved fire. Due to a high liquid component in aerosols, the fire residues condense to form a dense layer or film over a substrate. They are most notably visible on horizontal surfaces, appearing as a stain. Greater levels of residues will be found closer to the source but can be distributed throughout a building. Readily penetrates closed cabinets, wall cavities, and spaces that other forms of smoke do not.
Synthetic (Plastic) Smoke Residues: Thick, smeary residue from burned synthetic materials may contain corrosive chemicals. Material is unevenly and incompletely consumed, producing combustion particles that agglomerate, forming into large masses, though they are light and do not settle as other combustion particles. Plastic fire residues and some synthetic materials readily link together to form smoke webs. The light-weight particles can travel great distances and are redistributed by surface friction or air movement.
Protein Fire Residue: While black carbon particles may be absent, protein fires distribute an invisible, greasy film, which is often difficult to isolate and remove. The source of fuel (meats or other proteins) smolders under the heat from the stove or oven until consumed and reduced to ashes or charred bone fragments. Though often difficult to discern, protein residues may take on certain hues. These hues may include, but are not limited to:
- yellow
- amber
- orange
In severe cases, protein fires may cause yellow staining that cleaning cannot remove. The kitchen is usually the area with the most significant impact. Because combustion is slow, the airborne residues have more time to infiltrate cavities around kitchen cabinets and nearby closets. However, residues can spread and impact other areas by the exact mechanisms that drive visible smoke.
Furnace or Boiler Soot Residues: Furnace or boiler soot is produced by a malfunctioning fuel (usually oil) burner (or heat exchanger). Furnace or boiler soot can also result from a single incident, sometimes called a “puff back.” Puffbacks happen because the fuel fails to ignite appropriately, causing a buildup of the fuel vapors within the combustion chamber. When the burners finally ignite, the excess fuel causes an explosion within the burner chamber. This explosion causes accumulated soot residues to dislodge and broadcast into the exhaust and heating systems. The particles tend to be large and share similarities to those produced in plastic fires due to the petroleum component of the fuel. Forced air system blowers aid distribution throughout a building via ductwork. In non-forced air systems, the most significant quantities of soot will be found near the boiler and then distributed to upper areas by floor penetrations and indoor air currents.
Simple fire clean-up can include anything from smoke or odor to charred wood, drywall, and contents. In contrast, more complex fires include drug labs, chemical storage, exterior yard cleaning (soil scraping to burnt brush removal, etc.), or the complete removal of a structure. The debris removal process assessment and investigation information are critical to the RWP or Protocol. The debris removal process can be difficult and time-consuming as it often requires specialized experts, equipment, and techniques to ensure proper removal.
During or after the removal of structural debris, the restorer must address the contents and consider its actions. Contents are one of the most significant issues this industry deals with, whether performing services on or offsite, from start to finish. Contents are like their own little structures as they have their envelope, age, use, and exposure, not to forget the porosity of the finished interior materials to structural support. Contents cleaning and restoration may require a multidisciplinary approach that is unique to each individual piece. These will be considered for RWP or Protocol.
Contents will have multiple considerations, such as water, fire debris impact, smoke, and soot adsorption. What is the cost of cleaning versus buying new contents or the sentimental value of the object? Fire contents cleaning is a complex process that requires knowledgeable and trained professionals.
Once the cleaning and restoration work has been addressed, the contractor should perform a post-remediation evaluation (PRE). A third-party environmental consultant can conduct a post-remediation verification (PRV) if required.
Fire and smoke cleaning and restoration may require a multidisciplinary approach involving professionals from several fields of expertise. The IICRC, RIA, and ACAC train the restorer to clean and restore fire damage and assess and investigate a fire scene for RWP or protocol. Currently, we refer to RIA, ACAC, and IICRC-approved Fire and Smoke Training.
In conclusion, Fire Damage can range from simple to extraordinarily complex. Fire cleaning and restoration requires knowledge, training, and a basic understanding of current and past construction methods, materials, and building assemblies. Fire damage assessment and repair may require a multidisciplinary approach involving professionals from several fields.
References:
RIA – Guidelines Fire and Smoke Damage Repair
Additional Literature for Awareness and Knowledge.
The Red Guide to Recovery- Sean Scott
The Leadership Guide to Drying – Ken Larsen
EMSL – Fire & Smoke Damage Testing “Pocket Guide”
Baxter, D., Delia, A., Evans, S., Kovar, B., Technical Guide for Wildfire Impact Assessments for the OEHS Professional, AIHA, 2018
